Two years have passed. Nobody has come to kill me or threaten my daughter. I go through the days feeling numb and shut off from the world, I go to work at the same hospital I was at when I first met my husband, and with the money Lochlan left me, I buy my own small house down the road from my father. He’s comfortable in his retirement, spending his days reading the news, tinkering with odds and ends that need fixing around the house, and watching his grandchildren whenever he can. Admittedly, he’s left with Niamh the most. Caius comes every few weeks to check the shield and visit the family; for the most part, he keeps himself busy with other assignments. I think it hurts him too much to see me, as he knew Lochlan had volunteered to die in my place. It pains me just as much to see the sadness in my own eyes reflected back in his.
Ryan finished up his tour and decided to stay in New York with family. He traded one uniform for another; after becoming a police officer, he married Sophia, and they’re trying to have some babies of their own.
Luke has made a name for himself, as well. He owns his own gym now, catering to celebrity clientele and anyone with an overflowing wallet. His methods have always been unorthodox, his words vulgar and his spirit intense, and people seem to like that about him. With the increase in money, he opened up a salon for Katherine, and she’s not doing too bad for herself, either.
Things are good for everyone except me, and I’m fine with that. My family pushes me to get back into the dating pool, to stop simply being the sad widow and to get back out there, but I spend all my time on work and raising Niamh. I’m not interested in anyone aside from the man I had and then lost due to my own actions. The man who should be here now, to watch his daughter grow. She’s chatty and strong and independent; she can carry on full conversations, knows enough to keep her powers in check for the most part, and each day she surprises me with how smart she is. Lochlan would be overjoyed to see it.
When Aaron texts me out of the blue one day, I nearly don’t respond. It takes me a few days and a lot of nagging from Katherine to reply.
He knows I’m from New York, and coincidentally got a job offer at a college not far from where I live. He’s bringing his two sons, now seven and ten years of age, to live here. I’m not interested in romance or jokes or grabbing coffee, but he pleads with me to come and see his kids. We met before all this went down, and they’ve been insistent upon seeing me again.
In the middle of a Starbucks on my day off, Niamh in my lap and his two boys excitedly talking about their friends at school, we catch up. He’d been worried when the house burnt down and Ava turned up dead, and it didn’t help that Lochlan and I were never to be seen again.
Now we’re here. In New York, of all places, and I’ve agreed to show him around. I’ve bonded with his kids, he’s smitten with Niamh, and he’s still single. Nothing worked out for him, and I’m the depressed widow who’s just getting by.
It isn’t long before he has me laughing despite my best efforts not to open up. It’s also not long before we’re dating, taking our kids to events together, sharing looks and touching hands and spilling secrets.
He knows everything. I tell him about me, about Lochlan, about the countless dimensions, gods, warlocks, and ancient rules. He takes it slowly out of respect for my loss, knowing he’ll never come close to what I had with Lochlan. Nobody will. And because we work together, because he makes me laugh to distract me from the self-hatred, because he’s tender and caring and simply there, we move in together.
Another year passes. I’m practically the stepmother to Mason and Alex. I love them both, as I love Niamh, but I’m coasting. I try to love Aaron, and I succeed in that, but I’m not in love. It’ll never be true love. Mine came and went with the death of my husband.
Maybe one day I’ll find some spark or some light in the darkness, but the only thing keeping me tethered to this earth is my daughter. I live and breathe for her, and nothing else matters.
On a Sunday morning, I lie beneath Aaron as he moves inside me. The kids aren’t yet awake, so we take advantage of the alone time when we can. I take birth control religiously because three kids is more than enough, and Aaron is fine with that. He’s fine with everything, really. Fine with the fact that I can’t love him back in the same way that he loves me. Fine with whatever I say and do, fine with my mood swings and my anger and my depression. He’s just... fine.
I grasp his back and hike my legs up, opening myself up to him, and he responds with a kiss. He doesn’t deepen the thrusts or quicken the movement of his hips. He makes love to me, breathing quietly into my ear, brushing his lips across my throat in a tender, unhurried pace.
I groan and lift my hips to meet his. “Aaron, I won’t break. Just fuck me.”
He tries. He pushes into me harder this time, faster, but I can barely feel the difference. I sigh. “You don’t have to be so nice all the time. It doesn’t always have to be passionate and romantic.”
He stills. “Cora, you want me to practically kill you. Nothing is ever enough for you. It doesn’t feel right. It’s like you equate sex with violence, and I’m not that guy.”
I know he’s not. Not by a long shot. But I miss the fire and the spark I had before. I miss being primal and animalistic. Lochlan could be so tender and loving in one moment, and then a brutal opponent in the next. My muscles clench around Aaron’s dick in remembrance. “I’m a god, Aaron. You couldn’t hurt me if you tried.” I relax my legs and stare up at the ceiling. “Look, I know I have to piss you off sometimes. Use that. I’m trying to get off, but I can’t this way.”
There’s an unspoken acknowledgement between the two of us. Sex has been sparse. At first, I was okay with the sweetness of our encounters. I was okay with the satisfactory orgasms and the acceptance that I’d never have with him what I had with Lochlan. But his calm, gentle demeanor is getting on my last nerve.
“You don’t piss me off,” Aaron contends, and it only makes me angrier. “I know I don’t measure up, which can be frustrating, but I don’t feel comfortable abusing you so you can cum.”
He thinks this is abuse. He thinks I’m trying to punish myself for Lochlan’s death. He thinks I can’t just accept him for who he is, and maybe some days he has a point.
Fed up, I roll over until I’m on top. I grab the headboard and sit up on my haunches, and I know it’s a porn star move that’s uncomfortable to say the least, but it affords me the ability to slam down and hit deep.
Which is exactly what I do. Sleeping kids be damned, I hold on tightly and bounce up and down on his cock, not feeling nearly as full or as wet or as satisfied, but enough to do the trick. I fuck him like I hate him, and yes, I think of Lochlan. I remember the way we used to fuck. I remember the classroom escapades, the bathroom trysts, being bent over a couch and having my pussy beaten up like it owed him money. We had fire and spark and passion, enough to bottle up and destroy dimensions with. I had the ultimate bad boy fantasy with a man who loved me more than he loved his every breath, a man whom I loved just the same.
Aaron is... Aaron. Nice, friendly, spark-less Aaron. When I cum, I do it quietly. My limbs don’t quake, I don’t scream his name, and when it’s over, I don’t cuddle and get cutesy. I get up to wash off, throw on a robe, and make breakfast.
After the kids eat and disappear to the living room to fight over video games, Niamh comfortably playing with dolls in the corner, Aaron strolls in fresh from the shower. He eyes me, gives me a warm yet awkward smile, and sits down to eat the plate I’ve set out for him.
He chews thoughtfully, then stops to regard me. “I’m sorry.”
Again, the apologies. “It’s fine. You did nothing wrong. I’m the one who’s fucked up.”
He sets his fork down and stands. “You’re not, Cora. You went through a lot, I get that, and I’m more than happy to have you here. I love you, the boys love you, and I’m good with what I’ve got.”
I stare down at the pot I’ve been scrubbing. “You shouldn’t have to settle for me. I’ve been honest, Aaron, and I’ve been doing my best here, but you deserve better than me. I’m a mess.”
He crosses the divide between us and stands before me. “You lost the love of your life. It’ll take a long time to be okay with something like that, and I’ll be here as long as you let me. That’s a promise.”
I roll my eyes. “That’s just it, Aaron. You’re so nice, I feel awful saying anything. There’s never a fight, no disagreements, no angry sex or storming off. I know I can be a bitch sometimes, I’m insufferable, and then there’s you. You just take it with a smile and you’re good to go. Are you ever just pissed? Yell at me, do something!”
There’s shock in his eyes. “I don’t know what you want me to say. I love you. Yes, it’s been difficult, but you’re the one living with the nightmares and the flashbacks. I can’t force you to recover and be happy.” He throws up his hands in frustration. “Cora, I love you. All I want is for you to be happy. What do I need to do?”
“Fight me!” I yell, and I know I sound unreasonable and crazy, but I’m bored and I’m losing my mind with the mundane. “Be mad at me! I’m the worst girlfriend. I barely cook, I’m always at the hospital, I’m bitching more often than not. How are you so fine with everything?”
Finally, Aaron is at his breaking point. It took him long enough. Red in the face, confusion and desperation and only the barest hint of fury in his eyes, he snaps. “Because I’m not Lochlan! I’m not your husband! Jesus, Cora, it’s like you want me to push you away!”
Maybe I do. I’ll take anything at this point. I can’t take the compliments and kisses and loving glances. I want fireworks. I want out. I sigh, because we’re too deep in this now. We fit together because our kids fit together, and I’m with him because he’s yet to tire of me. I’m here because I know that if I can’t find love again with a man like Aaron, then I’m just plain broken. We’ve both settled after one too many heartbreaks, and for now, we have stability.
When Niamh stands and looks at me, concern in her eyes, I shake my head. I don’t need the magic consolation. I need to clear my head somewhere else. I take a deep breath and look back at Aaron. “I’m sorry,” I murmur, and he steps forward as I knew he would. His arms wrap around me and he kisses my hair, my forehead, my lips.
“Don’t worry about it,” he says, his voice soothing and his eyes kind. “I love you, Cora. I don’t like it when we fight.”
Any small disagreement is a fight to him. He grew up with parents who were constantly at odds, lived through their divorce, and swore to himself that he’d never cross the line and lose his shit like they did. So far, despite my ever-changing shifts in mood, he’s kept his promise.
He’s so nice, it’s suffocating. I relax into him in defeat and rest my head against his chest. “I love you, too.”
With that, it’s over. No games, no going days without communication. He fixes his problems head-on and with a level head. I fix my problems with alcohol and rage.
He agrees to watch the kids while I shower and change into my workout clothes for a run around the neighborhood. After giving everyone a kiss goodbye, I take off through the front door, my earphones blaring hard rock music, my mind elsewhere as I kneel in the driveway to tie a shoelace that had come undone.
When I stand, I slam into a tall, hard body, and I pale when I see who’s standing before me.
The phone in my hand clatters to the sidewalk, bringing my headphones with it. My heart thumps in my chest and my stomach churns. Tears spring to my eyes, my limbs growing weak.
“Lochlan?” I whisper.